Blogs / Explainable AI: Why We Need to Know How AI Makes Decisions

Explainable AI: Why We Need to Know How AI Makes Decisions

هوش مصنوعی قابل تفسیر: چرا باید بدانیم AI چگونه تصمیم می‌گیرد؟

Introduction

Imagine a doctor tells you that the hospital's AI system has diagnosed you with a specific disease and you need immediate treatment. But when you ask why and based on what evidence this diagnosis was made, the doctor responds: "I don't know, the system just gave this result." Would you trust such a diagnosis?
This is exactly the challenge we face today in the world of artificial intelligence. With the rapid advancement of deep learning and complex neural networks, AI models have achieved remarkable accuracy, but the problem is that most of these models operate like black boxes - they receive data, process it, and produce results without us being able to understand what exactly happened in this process.
Explainable AI (XAI) is the solution to this dilemma. This field strives to make AI models more transparent and help us understand why and how a model reached a particular conclusion. In this article, we'll deeply explore the concept of XAI, its importance, various techniques, applications, and challenges ahead.

Why Do We Need Explainable AI?

Trust and Social Acceptance

One of the biggest barriers to implementing AI in sensitive domains like medicine, law, and finance is lack of transparency. When we don't know how a model makes decisions, how can we trust it?
Research shows that users are more willing to use AI systems that can explain their decisions. This issue also holds special importance in AI ethics, as transparency is one of the core pillars of ethical technology use.

Accountability and Regulation

With the widespread use of AI, lawmakers worldwide are drafting new regulations. EU GDPR regulations and similar laws in other countries guarantee the right to explanation for users - meaning individuals have the right to know why an automated system made a particular decision about them.
Without interpretability, organizations cannot take responsibility for their models' decisions, and in case of errors, accountability will be impossible.

Detecting and Fixing Errors

Machine learning models can suffer from destructive biases present in training data. For example, a recruitment system might discriminate against female candidates compared to male ones due to bias in historical data.
Using XAI, we can identify and correct these biases. Interpretability tools show us which features the model bases its decisions on and whether these features are logical and fair.

Model Improvement and Optimization

A deeper understanding of how a model works helps developers identify weaknesses and improve the model. When we know which features have the most impact, we can perform better feature engineering and increase model performance.

Critical Applications

In domains such as medical diagnosis and treatment, autonomous vehicles, and cybersecurity, wrong decisions can have serious consequences. In such situations, interpretability is not just desirable but essential.

Difference Between Interpretability and Explainability

Although these two terms are often used interchangeably, they have subtle differences:
  • Interpretability: Means direct understanding without needing additional explanations of how the model works. Simple models like linear regression or small decision trees are inherently interpretable.
  • Explainability: Means the ability to provide understandable explanations about a complex model's decisions. Even if the model is complex, we can use tools that explain the results.
Simply put, interpretability is an inherent property of the model, while explainability can be added to the model post-hoc.

Types of Interpretation Methods in XAI

Inherently Interpretable Models

Some machine learning models are naturally interpretable due to their simple structure:

Linear and Logistic Regression

In these models, coefficients directly show how much each feature affects the final prediction. If the coefficient is positive, increasing that feature increases the output, and vice versa.

Decision Trees

Decision trees graphically display the exact decision-making path. You can follow all conditions and decisions from root to leaf.

If-Then Rules

Rule-based systems using "if condition A, then result B" structure are completely transparent and understandable.

Model-Specific Interpretation Methods

These techniques are designed for specific architectures:

Attention Mechanisms in Transformers

Transformer models and large language models use attention mechanisms that show which parts of the input the model focused on during processing. This is very useful in natural language processing.

Filter Visualization in CNNs

In convolutional neural networks, we can visualize filters of different layers to see what patterns each layer has learned - from edges and textures in early layers to complex objects in deeper layers.

Model-Agnostic Interpretation Methods

These techniques can be used for any type of model:

LIME (Local Interpretable Model-agnostic Explanations)

LIME helps us by creating a simple model (like linear regression) that approximates the complex model's behavior at a specific point. This method is very effective for explaining local decisions (a specific prediction).
For example, LIME can show why a financial prediction model rejected a loan - perhaps due to low credit history or high debt-to-income ratio.

SHAP (SHapley Additive exPlanations)

SHAP, based on game theory and Shapley values, calculates the contribution of each feature to the prediction. This method has strong mathematical foundations and provides consistent and reliable results.
SHAP is suitable for both analyzing individual cases (local) and understanding overall model behavior (global).

Partial Dependence Plots (PDP)

These plots show how changing one or two specific features affects the model output, while other features are kept constant.

Permutation Feature Importance

By randomly shuffling the values of a feature and measuring the decrease in model accuracy, we can determine that feature's importance. If shuffling a feature causes a sharp decrease in accuracy, that feature has high importance.

Example-Based Methods

These methods help explain decisions by providing similar or influential examples:

Counterfactual Explanations

This method answers the question: "What minimal changes to the input would change the outcome?"
For example: "If your annual income were $5,000 higher, your loan would be approved."

Prototypes and Criticisms

Identifying representative examples (that well represent a class) and critical examples (that differ from the general pattern) can help better understand decisions.

Practical Applications of XAI in Various Industries

Medicine and Healthcare

In disease diagnosis with AI, doctors need to know not only the diagnosis but also its reasons. XAI can:
  • Highlight suspicious areas in radiological images
  • Identify main risk factors for a disease
  • Help doctors make better clinical decisions
Real example: Skin cancer detection systems that not only provide malignancy probability but also show specific visual characteristics (like asymmetry, irregular color) that led to this diagnosis.

Financial Services

AI in financial analysis and algorithmic trading plays a key role, but transparency in this domain is critical:
  • Explaining reasons for loan rejection or approval
  • Identifying suspicious transactions and fraud
  • Explaining investment strategies to clients
  • Compliance with legal regulations

Justice System

Using AI in legal systems is very controversial. XAI can help increase transparency and fairness:
  • Explaining reasons for bail amount determination
  • Identifying factors affecting recidivism risk prediction
  • Ensuring no racial or gender discrimination

Recruitment and Human Resources

AI in recruitment can make the process more efficient, but it must be transparent:
  • Explaining why candidates were selected or rejected
  • Preventing unintentional discrimination
  • Providing constructive feedback to applicants

Autonomous Vehicles

In the automotive industry, XAI can:
  • Show why the car decided to brake or change lanes
  • Help analyze accidents and improve safety
  • Increase public trust in autonomous vehicles

Marketing and Advertising

In digital marketing, XAI can:
  • Explain why a specific campaign was successful
  • Identify which customer segments have the highest response
  • Help optimize content creation strategies

Challenges and Limitations of XAI

Balance Between Accuracy and Interpretability

One of the biggest challenges is the trade-off between accuracy and simplicity. Simpler models are usually more interpretable but have lower accuracy. On the other hand, complex models like deep neural networks have high accuracy but are harder to interpret.
The main question is: How much accuracy can we sacrifice for interpretability? The answer depends on the application type - in sensitive domains, a slight decrease in accuracy may be acceptable, but in some applications, high accuracy is the priority.

Complexity of Explanations

Sometimes the explanations themselves can be complex and incomprehensible. If the explanation requires specialized mathematical or statistical knowledge, it won't be useful for the average user.
The challenge is to provide explanations that are simple yet accurate. This requires designing appropriate user interfaces and providing explanations at different levels (from simple summaries to technical details).

Fidelity of Explanations

Do the provided explanations truly represent how the model works, or are they merely an approximation? Some XAI methods may provide explanations that differ from the model's actual mechanism.
This issue is particularly relevant in approximation methods like LIME. If explanations aren't faithful, they might mislead us and create false trust.

Computational Cost

Some XAI methods are very expensive and require considerable time to generate explanations. This issue can be problematic in real-time systems that need quick responses.

Cultural and Linguistic Differences

The way explanations are presented and understood can differ across cultures and languages. Designing XAI systems that can effectively communicate with different audiences is challenging.

Risk of Misuse

Too much information about how a model works can be used by attackers for Adversarial Attacks. Knowing which features the model bases decisions on can help them design inputs that fool the model.
This is a security dilemma: How can we maintain transparency without making the model vulnerable?

The Future of XAI: Toward More Transparent AI

Interpretable Deep Learning

Extensive research is underway to design new architectures that are inherently more interpretable. For example:
  • Attention-based Models: Using attention mechanisms that naturally show which parts the model focused on.
  • Neural-Symbolic Integration: Combining deep learning with logical reasoning.
  • Disentangled Representations: Learning representations that encode different features independently and interpretably.

Automatic and Adaptive XAI

The future lies in systems that:
  • Automatically select the best type of explanation based on user and situation
  • Adapt explanations to the user's knowledge level
  • Use user feedback to improve explanations

XAI in Multimodal Models

With the emergence of multimodal models that can simultaneously process text, images, audio, and other data types, we need more advanced XAI methods that can explain complex interactions between different modalities.

Standardization and Laws

Stricter laws regarding AI transparency are expected to be enacted. Organizations must prepare for compliance with these laws and make XAI an integral part of the model development process.

XAI for AGI

Moving toward Artificial General Intelligence (AGI), we need more sophisticated explanation systems. How can we explain multi-step reasoning that AGI systems might perform? This is one of the great challenges of the future.

XAI Tools and Libraries

For developers and researchers, various tools exist for implementing XAI:

SHAP (Python)

One of the most popular libraries for calculating Shapley values. Compatible with the Python ecosystem and TensorFlow, PyTorch, and Keras.

LIME

A flexible library usable for various models and data types (text, images, tables).

InterpretML (Microsoft)

A comprehensive suite of interpretable algorithms including EBM (Explainable Boosting Machine), Decision Rules, etc.

Captum (PyTorch)

A dedicated library for interpreting PyTorch models with a focus on deep neural networks.

Alibi (Seldon)

A powerful tool for generating Counterfactual Explanations and Anchor Explanations.

What-If Tool (Google)

A visual and interactive tool for analyzing model behavior, well integrated with TensorFlow.

Best Practices for Implementing XAI

Think About Interpretability from the Start

XAI shouldn't be an afterthought. From the early stages of project design, think about how you want to explain model decisions.

Know Your Audience

Explanations suitable for a machine learning expert aren't understandable for an end user. Adapt the technical level of explanations to the audience:
  • For developers: Technical details, weights, gradients
  • For analysts: Charts, feature importance, correlations
  • For end users: Simple explanations in natural language, concrete examples

Combine Multiple Methods

No single XAI method provides a complete picture. It's better to combine several different techniques to get a more comprehensive view.

Validate Explanations

Compare explanations with ground truth or ask domain experts to verify their logic.

Complete Documentation

Document all design decisions, methods used, and known limitations. This will be very helpful during audits or debugging.

Continuous Updates

As data and models change, the explanation system must also be updated. XAI isn't a one-time process but part of the model lifecycle.

XAI and Relationship with Other AI Concepts

XAI and Responsible AI

AI trustworthiness includes various dimensions: fairness, transparency, privacy preservation, reliability, and safety. XAI is the main pillar of transparency and helps achieve other dimensions as well.

XAI and Federated Learning

Federated learning, which preserves privacy, poses specific challenges for XAI. How can we explain a model trained on distributed and inaccessible data?

XAI and Prompt Engineering

In prompt engineering, we try to control model behavior through careful input design. XAI can show us why some prompts perform better than others.

XAI and AI Hallucination

Hallucination is one of the serious problems of language models. XAI can help identify when the model is fabricating information.

XAI and RAG

In Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG), explaining which sources were used to generate the response is itself a type of XAI that helps increase trust.

Case Studies: XAI in Practice

Case One: Heart Disease Diagnosis

A hospital used a machine learning model to predict heart attack risk. The model had high accuracy, but doctors didn't trust it. Using SHAP, it was revealed that the model relied too much on age and ignored some important factors like family history. After correction and feature balancing, doctors gained more confidence in the system and its use became widespread.

Case Two: Loan Approval at a Bank

A bank faced complaints from customers whose loans were rejected without clear reasons. By implementing XAI, the bank could provide transparent reasons: "Your loan was rejected due to high debt-to-income ratio (65% versus the 45% limit) and late payment history in the past 6 months." This transparency not only reduced complaints but also helped customers improve their financial situation.

Case Three: Online Advertising

An advertising platform used AI for marketing. Using PDP and Feature Importance, they discovered that time of day had much more impact than ad content. This insight led them to change their strategy and increase ROI by 40%.

Conclusion: A More Transparent Future

Explainable AI is no longer an optional feature but a necessity. As AI systems play an increasingly larger role in our daily lives, the need to understand how they work grows day by day.
XAI is a bridge between the complex world of machine learning and humanity's need for understanding and trust. By combining the high accuracy of advanced models with transparency and explainability, we can achieve a future of artificial intelligence that is both powerful and trustworthy.
But we must remember that XAI is still evolving. Many challenges lie ahead and more research is needed. From technical issues like interpreting very large models to social challenges like legislation and public acceptance.
Ultimately, the goal is to build systems that are not only intelligent but can communicate with us, explain their decisions, and earn our trust. This is what XAI promises us: a future where artificial intelligence is not a mysterious black box but a transparent and understandable partner.
Given current trends and massive investments in this field, we can hope to see significant advances in XAI in the coming years - advances that not only improve technology but also guide our society toward fairer, more transparent, and more responsible use of artificial intelligence.